Tree Ant wrote:So what exactly does count as BFRPG? If someone runs SG2 with D&D 5E, would that count?
Yes, though I wouldn't recommend it, not without converting. Part of testing a module is to see how it would run. Using a system with inflated numbers would not be an ideal good test IMO. But I wouldn't want to stop someone's momentum.
Tree Ant wrote:
I understand most of the original members wanted BFRPG only. Since I didn't feel strongly either way, I don't think I am well suited for this adjudication. If it were up to me, I would just let people run whatever.
There's no stopping general discussion about other systems and mentioning other groups, but the description of the group clearly says "BFRPG related". Anything else would be a degradation of that topic, IMO. It's like if folks from ENWorld started taking all their 4e discussion over to DF; it just wouldn't be appropriate; moderators would have to move it all to an "other systems" sub-forum or something. Tough call, since we want the community, but not necessarily the noise (or potentially the spam.)