Basic Fantasy RPG Forums

artikid wrote:@Solomoriah, re-enchantment using Magic research rules?

Something like this (including a good armorer to hammer out the dents).

Something I thought of that should be in these rules.

Tower Shields (Kite/Large Shields)... perhaps limit these to Fighter Only (as in Clerics cannot use);
and another change on this line of thinking,
Bucklers may be utilized by Thieves.

Personally, I am of the mindset that a MU could potentially use a buckler as well, but I doubt the hardliners here would think similarly.

I'd be okay with letting any class have a buckler, and maybe even shields. My experience is that they're pretty intuitive.

Under shield splintering, this line seems confusing (at least to me )

If the character is not proficient with shields (like a Thief) deduct 1, add his specialization bonus if specialized.

It sounds like a character or is not proficient with shields could still be specialized.

Maybe something more like

A character who is specialized with shields (see combat options) adds his specialization bonus to the damage reduction, while a character not proficient with shields (like a thief) deducts 1.

New version with clarifications.
Cheers
artikid

EDIT: last release up in later post

I expanded some of the armor descriptions for the Equipment Emporium. If you like any of it, you can work it in here. I would recommend adding something on creature size - it's in the core (the halfling part, at least), but not always noticed.

Last release

If I were to suggest something, it would be that Shields should be tweaked a bit... nothing necessarily wrong, but for reason of simplification, neatness/tidyness of the rule (and minimal change at that):

Buckler +1 AC, but only against 1 opponent per round.
M. Shield +1 AC (any number of foes) - this is the standard shield.
Tower Shield +2 AC, +4 vs Missiles

The Tower Shield Change comes from reading p.46 about 'cover and concealment'. It is a bit of an extrapolation and logical application of those rules (because the rules do not cover this directly). Review that section to see where I am going with my thinking here. The Tower Shield counts as a portion of hard cover (so I would double the standard value of +2 to +4).

Of course, this is debatable... but I throw it out there to consider.

Buckler presents an interesting case alongside two-weapon fighting. As-is, it's a melee blocker, useless against missiles. The other common route is to make it only good for one attacker.

Now when you add two-weapon fighting,one-hit bucklers become obsolete. You get +1AC vs. 1 opponent if you use your off-hand weapon defensively. There is a slight advantage for bucklers if you allow them to be used against a single missile strike.

I prefer Smoot's shields. That's how I'd do it if I did multiple shield types.